Is a previously unheard-of First Nation just Canada’s latest Pretendian case?

Last Updated: June 18, 2024By

Identity Dispute: Battle Over Land Rights in Kawartha Lakes


In the serene landscape off a quiet country road, 100 miles northeast of bustling Toronto, lies the headquarters of the Kawartha Lakes First Nation. Amidst signs enticing the purchase of all-terrain vehicles, scribbled messages on three weather-beaten structures lament governmental misconduct.

Standing tall amidst this scene is a 26ft tipi, a symbolic beacon surrounded by flags fluttering in the breeze. While banners pay homage to missing and murdered Indigenous women and victims of Canada’s residential schools, Confederate flags wave alongside, painting a picture of cultural collision.


To its modest membership of 20, this place embodies the essence of Canada’s newest First Nation. Yet, for seven local Indigenous chiefs, it represents a bold attempt at deception, a threat to their hard-won rights.

In recent times, Canada has grappled with an unsettling trend of “Pretendian” cases, where individuals falsely lay claim to Indigenous heritage. Simultaneously, the appropriation of Indigenous symbols and slogans has become commonplace among the far-right factions in the country.


The members of Kawartha Lakes First Nation argue for exemption from laws and taxes, echoing the sentiments of the extremist sovereign citizens’ movement. Their emergence raises concerns about the exploitation of Indigenous identity for territorial claims or concessions from local authorities.

About two months ago, William Denby, self-proclaimed “chief” of the Kawartha group, embarked on a spree of emails to local chiefs and government officials. His messages, often in bold capitals, merged grievances with audacious assertions.


Denby protested against the encroachment of farmland for housing, levelling broad accusations of corruption. He also laid claim to the hereditary leadership of a purported Indigenous nation, asserting rights over nearly 5,800 square miles of land.

Initially dismissive, Taynar Simpson, chief of Alderville First Nation, eventually engaged with Denby. Simpson, renowned for his expertise in Indigenous genealogy, sought evidence to substantiate Denby’s claims but found none.


In a peculiar turn of events, Denby asserted before the Kawartha Lakes city council that Simpson’s nation had ceded all authority to him, a claim vehemently denied by Simpson.

Alarmed by the group’s audacity, Simpson and six other chiefs issued a rare joint statement, denouncing Denby’s group for making baseless assertions and threatening legal action to protect their rights.


Denby rebuffed these accusations, vowing to counter with a lawsuit for defamation. The city of Kawartha Lakes also refuted Denby’s assertions, labeling them as detrimental to legitimate Indigenous rights holders.

Denby’s purported Indigenous ancestry came under scrutiny by a local genealogy enthusiast, who found no evidence to support his claims. Despite Denby’s assertions of Ojibwe and Mohawk lineage, his ancestry remains unsubstantiated.

Recent attempts to reach Denby at his camp were futile, with his whereabouts unknown. His associate, Steven Lesperance, declined to comment on the matter.

Denby’s legal troubles escalated when he was arrested and charged with criminal harassment and intimidation, following threatening emails sent to city councillors.

This incident underscores a broader concern: the far-right’s exploitation of Indigenous identity to assert land rights, posing a threat to legitimate Indigenous groups.

As Canada contemplates self-governance legislation for Indigenous nations, experts fear sophisticated groups could manipulate the system to supersede existing rights-holders.

Chief Simpson sees parallels between Denby’s actions and the colonial legacy, as both seek to assert control over ancestral lands.

The struggle for land rights in Kawartha Lakes epitomizes a deeper conflict over identity and sovereignty, echoing the enduring legacy of colonialism in Canada.

latest video

news via inbox

Nulla turp dis cursus. Integer liberos  euismod pretium faucibua

Leave A Comment